Explained: Amazing Stories Season 1 Episode 1: "The Cellar" Ending


Before we delve into the intricacies of "The Cellar," let's take a moment to appreciate the revival of Steven Spielberg's iconic "Amazing Stories." The 2020 reboot pays homage to the charm of its predecessor while infusing a modern sensibility.

The resurrection of this classic anthology series not only taps into the nostalgia of longtime fans but also introduces a new generation to the magic of storytelling. As we explore "The Cellar," keep in mind the series' overarching theme of transporting characters into extraordinary situations, echoing the spirit of Spielberg's original vision.

Plot Summary

Our tale kicks off with brothers Sam (played by the Dylan O’Brien) and Jake (portrayed by Micah Stock), knee-deep in the renovation of an old farmhouse. Little did they anticipate that this seemingly routine project would become a portal to a bygone era.

Sam and Jake - Amazing Stories S01 E01 The Cellar - Apple TV+
Image Credit: Apple TV+

Sam, portrayed by the Dylan O’Brien, working diligently in the farmhouse's cellar when an unexpected thunderstorm erupts. Lightning crackles, and before you know it, Sam finds himself transported back to the year 1919. A classic case of "wrong place, wrong time" or, in this instance, "right place, wrong century."

Sam and Evelyn in the past - Amazing Stories S01 E01 The Cellar - Apple TV+
Image Credit: Apple TV+

Enter Evelyn, a character brought to life by the talented Victoria Pedretti. As Sam navigates the challenges of this newfound time warp, he stumbles upon Evelyn, a young woman ensnared in societal expectations and arranged marriages. Their clandestine romance unfolds against the backdrop of a forbidden love, echoing shades of timeless romantic dramas.

Just when you thought you had the narrative figured out, a twist unfurls. Sam, our intrepid time-traveler, ends up trapped in 1919, while Evelyn finds herself marooned in the hustle and bustle of 2019. The unexpected switch leaves our characters facing the conundrum of love across the boundaries of time.

Ending Explained

As the curtain falls on this time-traveling saga, the pace quickens, and the narrative takes unexpected turns. The final moments of "The Cellar" demand our full attention, as loose ends are tied, and destinies are sealed.

Evelyn successful singer in 2034 - Amazing Stories S01 E01 The Cellar - Apple TV+
Image Credit: Apple TV+

Sam, our intrepid time-traveler, gets a sneak peek into the future – specifically, the year 2034. A momentary glimpse reveals Evelyn as a successful singer, serenading her little boy. This poignant scene sets the stage for the emotional rollercoaster that follows.

Sam in the past and Evelyn in the present reading letters - Amazing Stories S01 E01 The Cellar - Apple TV+
Image Credit: Apple TV+

Now, pay close attention as Sam faces a pivotal moment when a beam traps him in the cellar. Here's where the plot thickens – Sam, having glimpsed Evelyn's future in 2034, understands the sacrifice required. Accepting his fate with grace, Sam writes heartfelt letters to both Evelyn and his brother Jake. These letters become the conduits for messages of survival, love, and purpose.

Evelyn with her child in 2034 - Amazing Stories S01 E01 The Cellar - Apple TV+
Image Credit: Apple TV+

The burning question that lingers like a melody – who is the father of Evelyn's child in 2034? The plot takes a tantalizing twist here. While convention might point to Sam, the timeline doesn't quite sync up. The mystery deepens, leaving us to ponder if Sam's brother Jake could be the unsung hero. However, the show tantalizingly leaves the father's identity shrouded in mystery, perhaps symbolizing that some threads of fate are meant to remain untangled.

Father of Evelyn's Child

The mystery of Evelyn's child's paternity is like a puzzle missing a crucial piece. As we sift through the clues, various possibilities emerge, each adding a layer of intrigue to the narrative.

Is Sam the Likely Father? The conventional love story trope would point to our time-traveling hero, Sam, as the probable father. However, as we scrutinize the timelines and do a bit of chronological arithmetic, it appears that Sam's stint in 1919 might not align with the age of Evelyn's son in 2034.

Evelyn and Jake - Amazing Stories S01 E01 The Cellar - Apple TV+
Image Credit: Apple TV+

Enter the unexpected contender – Jake, Sam's brother. While it might seem a tad too convenient, the storyline drops subtle hints that make Jake a plausible candidate. As we navigate the twists and turns of the narrative, one can't help but wonder if fate has a penchant for surprises, perhaps weaving Jake into the fabric of Evelyn's future.

As we grapple with the possibilities, "The Cellar" keeps us on the edge with a deliberately open-ended resolution. The father's identity remains a well-guarded secret, challenging our assumptions and allowing the imagination to run wild. It's a narrative choice that adds a layer of complexity, inviting viewers to ponder the untold stories that exist beyond the frame.

Born for Different Times

Sam is like a lost soul in the labyrinth of 2019, surrounded by a sea of choices but stifled by indecision. Contrast that with Evelyn, trapped in 1919, a time where opportunities for women were scant, dreams often deferred, and societal norms dictated the course of their lives. Born in different epochs, their backgrounds are a study in contrasts.

Sam and Evelyn - Amazing Stories S01 E01 The Cellar - Apple TV+
Image Credit: Apple TV+

Sam, grappling with the burden of too many choices, finds purpose and contentment in the simplicity of 1919. On the flip side, Evelyn, restricted by the constraints of her time, discovers freedom and opportunity in the bustling landscape of 2019. Their struggles, born of the times they inhabit, become the crucible that forges their characters and propels them toward destinies unimaginable.

As the sands of time shift, so do our characters. Trapped in 1919, Sam discovers solace and fulfillment in a straightforward life, channeling his construction skills into building a business. Evelyn, transported to 2019, seizes the chance to pursue her passion for singing, basking in the freedoms afforded by modern society. It's a testament to the resilience of the human spirit, adapting and flourishing in the unique challenges presented by their respective epochs.

In "The Cellar," the concept of being born for different times unfolds as a poignant exploration of fate, choice, and the indomitable human spirit.

Real Meaning of "The Cellar": Fate

At the heart of "The Cellar" beats the drum of fate, orchestrating the destinies of our protagonists, Sam and Evelyn. Their journey, shaped by the whims of time, becomes a poignant exploration of how the threads of destiny intertwine, weaving a narrative that transcends eras. Fate, it seems, is the silent architect guiding their steps.

As we traverse the time-worn paths of 1919 and the neon-lit avenues of 2019, "The Cellar" offers a subtle commentary on the advancements and pitfalls of modern society. In 1919, women faced limited choices, bound by societal expectations. Fast forward to 2019, and the landscape has shifted, opening doors but also presenting the challenges of too many choices. The episode prompts us to reflect on the evolution of society and the intricacies that come with progress.

In the dance of time, Sam and Evelyn discover their true selves when thrust into contrasting eras. Sam, a man adrift in the choices of modernity, finds purpose and contentment in the simplicity of 1919. Evelyn, constrained by the norms of her time, blossoms in the freedom of 2019. Their respective journeys underscore the idea that sometimes, finding one's true self requires a leap across the chasm of time.

"The Cellar," beyond being a captivating love story, emerges as a meditation on fate, societal shifts, and the eternal quest for self-discovery.

Director and Cast's Interpretation

According to co-showrunner Edward Kitsis, the essence of "The Cellar" lies in the intertwined destinies of Sam and Evelyn. He suggests that these two characters needed each other at specific junctures in their lives to become the individuals they were meant to be.

In essence, the episode becomes a poetic exploration of people existing out of time, searching for their rightful places. Kitsis' interpretation adds a layer of depth to the narrative, underscoring the idea that sometimes, individuals come into our lives at precisely the right moment to catalyze our growth.

Adam Horowitz, in discussing "The Cellar," sheds light on the creative challenge of surprising the audience while maintaining a happy ending. The revelation that Sam and Evelyn end up on separate paths is, to Horowitz, the happy ending.

The episode, as the premiere of the rebooted Amazing Stories, sets the stage for a season that aims to blend surprise with emotional resonance. Horowitz's perspective invites us to appreciate the delicate balance between unexpected twists and the satisfaction of a well-rounded conclusion.

"The Cellar" presents a love story entwined with time travel, laying the foundation for a season that promises wonder, possibility, and imagination.

Wrap Up

"The Cellar" catapults us into a world of love, time travel, and sacrifice. Sam and Evelyn, born for different times, dance through the decades, leaving an indelible mark on each other's destinies. The ending, though bittersweet, showcases the power of sacrifice and the unpredictable dance of fate.

If "The Cellar" has left you yearning for more tales that tug at the heart and spark the imagination, I encourage you to dive deeper into the reimagined Amazing Stories series. With each episode promising a unique blend of emotion, surprise, and wonder, the series unfolds as a tapestry of narratives waiting to be explored.

Let the magic of Amazing Stories transport you to realms where the ordinary transforms into the extraordinary. It's a journey worth taking, filled with moments that linger in the heart long after the credits roll.

Watch "Amazing Stories" on Apple TV+.

Explained Amazing Stories Season 1 Episode 1 The Cellar Ending

Author: Lia Chez

Author/Writer - Lia Chez

Say hello to Lia Chez! When she's not basking under the sun or owning the city's nightlife, Lia's living her dream life. With a passion for fashion-tech and a heart tuned to pop beats, she's our style and music maven. Lia delves deep into the American music scene, Movies & TV Shows, dishing out the juiciest entertainment news with a dash of humor. With her, every day's a beach bash, and every night's a city lights spectacle!

Leave a Comment

thirteen − twelve =