"It's a Wonderful Knife" (2023) Ending Explained: Aurora & Alternate Realities

Set in the quaint town of Angel Falls, the Christmas comedy-horror, "It's a Wonderful Life," unfolds the gripping tale of the Carruthers family.

Mayor Henry Waters, played with psychotic flair by Justin Long, has ambitious plans for a luxury shopping complex, and to achieve his dreams, he targets Roger Evans' property. David Carruthers, former employee turned ally, tries to persuade Roger, unleashing a chain of events that delve into the dark side of this seemingly idyllic town.

In "It's a Wonderful Knife," Justin Long delivers an absolutely hysterical performance that adds a unique flavor to the film. Long's presence has become synonymous with a horror-centric comeback, and his role in this holiday slasher only solidifies his impact on the genre.

Plot Overview

In "It's a Wonderful Knife," the story unfolds in the charming town of Angel Falls, where the holiday spirit is supposed to be in full swing. Little do the residents know that beneath the tinsel and mistletoe lies a tale of suspense, horror, and a dash of holiday cheer.

The Carruthers family - It's a Wonderful Knife - RLJE Films, Shudder
Image Credit: RLJE Films, Shudder

The Carruthers family become the unsuspecting protagonists caught in the web of Angel Falls' eerie predicament. Mayor Henry Waters, a character with ambitions as grand as his name suggests, thrusts the town into a dilemma. The plot thickens as family dynamics intertwine with the mayor's insidious plans, creating a concoction of suspense, drama, and a touch of holiday magic.

Mayor Henry Waters's eyeing a luxury shopping complex, and to achieve this, he needs Roger Evans to part with his property. As we peel back the layers of the mayor's motivations, we uncover a cunning man driven not by festive spirit but by wealth and control.

Carruthers family becomes entangled in the mayor's machinations and the chilling events unfold in pursuit of his ambitious dreams. Winnie Carruthers, played by Jane Widdop, is a young high schooler caught in the chilling grasp of a town turned sinister. She's grappling with a tragedy that's stolen her Christmas spirit.

Cara's death by The killer - It's a Wonderful Knife - RLJE Films, Shudder
Image Credit: RLJE Films, Shudder

The plot takes a sharp turn with the tragedy of Cara's death, Winnie's best friend. Cara, played by Hana Huggins, becomes the victim of a deranged masked murderer known as The Angel. In the aftermath of Cara's death, we embark on Winnie's journey of self-discovery and resilience.

The trauma and loss push her to a breaking point, leading her to make a wish that catapults her into an alternate reality. It's in this twisted world that Winnie must confront her fears, grapple with her family's altered dynamics, and ultimately find the strength to undo the wish that led her here.

The Killer's Identity

It all starts innocently enough when Henry Waters and David Carruthers, in pursuit of their ambitious plans, visit Roger Evans' house to convince him to sell his property. Little do they know, this encounter sets off a chain of events that will shatter the town's tranquility. Roger, staunchly refusing to part with his land, becomes the first victim in a nightmarish sequence of events.

The killer donned in a creepy mask and white robes - It's a Wonderful Knife - RLJE Films, Shudder
Image Credit: RLJE Films, Shudder

The killer, donned in a creepy mask and white robes, embarks on a murderous spree. The unsuspecting townsfolk, including the best friends Winnie and Cara, become pawns in this deadly game.

Mayor Henry Waters The killer - It's a Wonderful Knife - RLJE Films, Shudder
Image Credit: RLJE Films, Shudder

But the real shocker comes when the mask is finally removed, revealing none other than the town's mayor, Henry Waters, as the demented murderer. The very person pushing for progress and prosperity is, in fact, the source of Angel Falls' darkest nightmare.

In a gripping climax, Winnie finds herself face to face with the killer who terrorized her town. In a bid to save her brother Jimmy and herself, Winnie takes matters into her own hands.

Winnie's Journey to Make Things Right

In a desperate quest to unravel the mysteries of this alternate reality, Winnie Carruthers turns to her own father for help. However, what transpires is beyond her wildest nightmares. The once honest and caring David Carruthers seems to have taken a dark turn.

Winnie's plea for assistance falls on deaf ears as her father, now entangled in the web of the sinister Mayor Henry Waters, dismisses her claims. David, who was once a victim of Henry Waters' machinations, has now become a puppet in the mayor's twisted game.

David Carruthers takes dark turn as The killer in Winnie's Alternate reality - It's a Wonderful Knife - RLJE Films, Shudder
Image Credit: RLJE Films, Shudder

The revelation hits Winnie hard, forcing her to confront not only the external threat posed by the killers but also the internal betrayal within her own family. The emotional weight of the situation adds layers to the horror, as the person she hoped to turn to becomes an unexpected adversary.

Armed with this newfound knowledge, Winnie faces a difficult decision – to confront and defeat not just the external threat posed by Henry Waters but also the internal menace within her own father. It's a battle not just against the killers but against the shadows that have cast a pall over her family and town.

But, all this is a part of Winnie's alternate reality.

The Ending: Winnie's Return to "Wonderful Life"

What sets this holiday horror flick apart from the rest is its remarkably heartfelt and gentle tone. As we reach the climax, the movie takes a turn more reminiscent of a Hallmark holiday special than a traditional horror finale.

Mayor Henry Waters in Winnie's Alternate reality - It's a Wonderful Knife - RLJE Films, Shudder
Image Credit: RLJE Films, Shudder

Winnie, having faced the horrors of an alternate reality, finally returns to her "Wonderful Life." The once distorted family dynamics are now restored, with her brother Jimmy alive and well, her mother no longer drowning in sorrow, and her father free from the clutches of a deranged serial killer. The reunion is nothing short of a Christmas miracle, and the gentle tone underscores the importance of family bonds.

Winnie and Bernie in Wonderful Life - It's a Wonderful Knife - RLJE Films, Shudder
Image Credit: RLJE Films, Shudder

But wait, there's more! As Winnie settles into her familiar life, a revelation about Bernie's fate adds a poignant layer to the narrative. Bernie, having retained memories from the alternate reality, shares a bittersweet truth. This Christmas was supposed to be her last, and it was Winnie's unexpected bond that saved her. Touched by this revelation, Winnie and Bernie decide to make the most of their newfound connection, choosing to spend Christmas together.

In this heartwarming ending, "It's a Wonderful Knife" manages to balance the eerie with the endearing, leaving us with a sense of joy and gratitude. After all, what's Christmas without a sprinkle of horror and a dash of heartfelt warmth?

Flawed Logic and Parody Elements

"It's a Wonderful Knife" ventures into the realm of parody, adding comedic elements to the classic horror recipe. Justin Long's hysterical performance, the over-the-top kills, and the overall tone bring a satirical twist to the genre. It's as if the film is saying, "Sure, it's a horror movie, but let's not take ourselves too seriously."

Aurora Borealis in town of Angel Falls - It's a Wonderful Knife - RLJE Films, Shudder
Image Credit: RLJE Films, Shudder

The somewhat perplexing connection between the aurora borealis and alternate realities is an interesting plot device that, while captivating, might raise a few eyebrows. Winnie's journey between realities tied to the aurora borealis feels a bit like a leap of logic, or maybe it's just the film's way of adding a touch of magic to the horror. Whether intentional or a delightful mishmash of holiday absurdity, it certainly keeps us on our toes.

In the maze of flawed logic and embracing the parody elements, it's clear that "It's a Wonderful Knife" doesn't shy away from bending the rules of conventional horror.


Much like the kaleidoscope of lights in the aurora borealis, audience reactions to "It's a Wonderful Knife" vary widely. Some folks have embraced the film's unique blend of horror and comedy, relishing in the absurdity of a holiday-themed slasher.

On the flip side, there are those who found the film's logic a bit like trying to untangle Christmas lights. The connection between the aurora borealis and alternate realities left some scratching their heads, questioning whether it was intentional humor or just a plot hiccup.

Winnie Carruthers being chased by The killer - It's a Wonderful Knife - RLJE Films, Shudder
Image Credit: RLJE Films, Shudder

Fans of the film have praised its festive atmosphere, the unexpected depth of character development, and the satisfying blend of horror and heart. Justin Long's return to the horror scene has garnered positive attention, with many applauding his comedic prowess in the midst of the macabre.

On the other side, some critics have pointed out the film's moments where the horror takes a backseat to the holiday cheer, making it feel more like a Christmas special than a traditional slasher.

It seems the film's willingness to dance between horror and parody had some viewers happily tapping their feet and others doing a cautious two-step.

Wrap Up

Snowy landscapes bathed in the glow of Christmas lights, laughter echoing through the air, and, of course, a masked killer on the loose. It's a concoction that defies the norms of both genres, delivering a holiday horror experience that's both chilling and heartwarming.

The film's journey through the quaint town of Angel Falls, with its quirky characters and sinister mayor, takes us on a rollercoaster of emotions. From the highs of festive funny moments to the lows of shocking murders, it's a ride that keeps you guessing and gasping in equal measure.

"It's a Wonderful Knife" is a film that dared to blur the lines between horror and holiday joy, offering a fresh perspective on what a Christmas slasher could be.

Watch "It's a Wonderful Knife" on Amazon Prime Video.

It's a Wonderful Knife (2023) Ending Explained Aurora & Alternate Realities

Author: Mary Taylor

Author/Writer - Mary Taylor

Introducing Mary Taylor! When she's not gardening or running her household like a superhero, she's a wordsmith extraordinaire. With her keyboard and a sharp eye, she dives into the world of Movies & TV Shows, crafting articles that could star in their own Entertainment Enigma.

Leave a Comment

thirteen − 3 =