'Super Mario Bros. Movie' Review: Did the Movie Live Up to the Hype?


Growing up in the '90s, my childhood was deeply intertwined with the adventures of Super Mario. I can vividly recall those days spent at a friend's house, huddled around the Nintendo Entertainment System (NES), as we embarked on a pixelated journey with the iconic plumber. The sheer joy of stomping Goombas, leaping across treacherous pits, and rescuing Princess Peach filled our afternoons with endless excitement.

However, my recent encounter with "The Super Mario Bros. Movie" left me yearning for the magic of those cherished memories. This highly-anticipated animated blockbuster, produced by Illumination, should have been a nostalgic power-up for fans like me. Instead, it turned out to be a letdown, a disappointment that failed to capture the essence of the beloved franchise.

The Super Mario Bros. Movie

The movie kicks off in Brooklyn, where the plumbers Mario (voiced by Chris Pratt) and Luigi (voiced by Charlie Day) are trying to establish their plumbing business. The initial scenes pay homage to Nintendo's legacy with subtle Easter eggs, triggering a sense of nostalgia among fans. There's even a clever side-scrolling race that mirrors the classic games.

However, the plot takes a puzzling turn as Mario and Luigi stumble upon a massive chamber of pipes beneath Brooklyn and are inexplicably transported to the Mushroom Kingdom. This vibrant realm is under threat from the villainous Bowser (voiced by Jack Black), who is bent on seizing the Super Star and making Princess Peach (voiced by Anya Taylor-Joy) his bride.

The Super Mario Bros. Movie Still Levels - Illumination
Image Credit: Illumination

Super Mario was more than just a video game; it was a part of my childhood, a portal to a world where imagination knew no bounds. I fondly recall the hours spent navigating Mario through perilous levels, discovering hidden power-ups, and reveling in the joy of completing each stage. It wasn't just a game; it was an adventure that ignited the kid in me.

Sadly, "The Super Mario Bros. Movie" failed to recapture that enchantment. It emerged as an animation that felt devoid of soul, as if it were created by a machine fed with data and imagery from the games. The film relied heavily on references and nostalgia, desperately pleading with viewers to rekindle their affection for the franchise.

As a longtime fan, I longed for a movie that would reignite the spark of imagination and recapture the thrill of playing Mario games. I hoped to witness a creative and ambitious endeavor that would pay homage to the series' rich history. However, what I got was a movie as hollow as a trailer, lacking creativity and ambition.

The Adventurous Plot

The film begins in the familiar setting of Brooklyn, where Mario and Luigi embark on their plumbing business. Nostalgia abounds in these scenes, with subtle Nintendo references bringing a smile to the faces of fans. There's even a clever moment where the brothers engage in a side-scrolling race, a nod to their gaming roots.

However, the story takes an unexpected turn when Mario and Luigi discover an underground chamber of pipes that transports them to the Mushroom Kingdom. Here, they find themselves facing the menacing Bowser, who seeks to conquer the kingdom and marry Princess Peach. The fate of this fantastical realm hangs in the balance as the brothers are thrust into an epic adventure.

The Super Mario Bros. Movie Still team - Illumination
Image Credit: Illumination

As Mario embarks on his quest, he encounters Princess Peach, who introduces him to a plethora of power-ups. The iconic question-mark blocks come to life as Mario grows, shrinks, and even transforms into a raccoon. Along the way, familiar elements from the games, such as Donkey Kong and Rainbow Road, make appearances, leading to the inevitable showdown to save the day.

"The Super Mario Bros. Movie" adheres to a formulaic plot, leaving little room for storytelling innovation. It leans heavily on visual and character references, cobbling them together into a 92-minute film. The movie falls short of taking creative risks, a missed opportunity to truly elevate the beloved franchise.

Lackluster Script and Storytelling

As I delved deeper into "The Super Mario Bros. Movie," it became painfully clear that the film's script and storytelling lacked the depth and ingenuity I had hoped for. What should have been a captivating narrative felt more like a checklist of Mario-themed set pieces and references hastily strung together.

The movie played it safe, adhering to a formula that felt overly familiar and uninspired. While it's understandable to want to pay homage to the source material, there was a noticeable absence of creativity and innovation in the storytelling. The plot followed a predictable arc, leaving little room for surprises or fresh interpretations of the Mario universe.

"The Super Mario Bros. Movie" missed a golden opportunity to craft a truly unique and engaging narrative. With a world as expansive and imaginative as the Mushroom Kingdom, the possibilities for storytelling are limitless. It's disappointing that the film chose to tread well-worn paths instead of exploring new horizons.

Voice Acting and Characterization

One aspect of the film that did pique my interest was the voice acting and characterization. It's no secret that the casting choices for Mario and Luigi, with Chris Pratt and Charlie Day respectively, raised eyebrows when they were first announced. However, they brought their own quirky charm to the characters, infusing them with a sense of humor and personality that added a fresh twist.

Chris Pratt, known for his roles in "Parks and Recreation" and the "Guardians of the Galaxy" series, offered a different take on Mario's iconic voice. While it may take some getting used to, his enthusiastic portrayal brought a lively energy to the character. Charlie Day's Luigi, with his signature nervous yet endearing demeanor, was a delightful match.

The voice cast as a whole managed to capture the essence of their respective characters, from Anya Taylor-Joy's regal Princess Peach to Jack Black's gruff and menacing Bowser. These performances injected life into the familiar faces of the Mushroom Kingdom, making them feel like old friends.

One standout performance came from Seth Rogen, who voiced Donkey Kong. Rogen's interpretation of the lovable ape was a surprising highlight of the film. His comedic timing and distinctive voice lent a fun and memorable dimension to the character. Donkey Kong's moments on screen were filled with laughter and charm, thanks in large part to Rogen's contribution.

While "The Super Mario Bros. Movie" may have stumbled in its script and storytelling, it was not without its bright spots. The voice cast breathed life into the beloved characters. Despite its shortcomings, this film has left me hopeful that future adaptations of the Mushroom Kingdom will strike a better balance between nostalgia and innovation.

Nostalgia vs. Substance

As I continued my journey through "The Super Mario Bros. Movie," I couldn't help but notice the ongoing tug-of-war between nostalgia and substance. The film seemed to be at odds with itself, trying to balance the desire to honor the beloved video game franchise's legacy while also delivering a compelling story.

One undeniable strength of the movie was its faithful nostalgia. It was evident that the creators had a deep appreciation for the Super Mario universe, and they meticulously crafted scenes and references that would warm the hearts of long-time fans. From iconic power-ups like the Super Mushroom to familiar characters and settings, the film was a love letter to the franchise.

Despite its nostalgic charm, "The Super Mario Bros. Movie" struggled with character development. While the characters themselves were instantly recognizable, they often felt one-dimensional. It left me wishing for more depth and complexity in their personalities, as well as their relationships with each other.

Visual Spectacle and Animation

One area where the movie undeniably excelled was in its visual spectacle and animation. The Mushroom Kingdom burst to life in vibrant, eye-popping detail. Every frame was a testament to the creativity and craftsmanship of the animation team. From the lush landscapes to the zany action sequences, it was a feast for the eyes.

"The Super Mario Bros. Movie" accomplished something remarkable by bringing the Mushroom Kingdom to life in a way that felt tangible and immersive. It was thrilling to see familiar locales like the neon-lit streets of Toad Town and the treacherous lava-filled caverns of Bowser's Castle rendered with such care and attention to detail.

Throughout the movie, I couldn't help but grin at the countless references and Easter eggs sprinkled throughout. It was a delight to spot nods to classic Super Mario games, hidden secrets, and inside jokes that only true fans would catch. These moments of recognition added an extra layer of enjoyment to the viewing experience.

The Soundtrack and Its Role

Ah, the soundtrack of a movie – an often unsung hero that can elevate the entire cinematic experience. In "The Super Mario Bros. Movie," the music played a vital role in shaping the mood and atmosphere of the Mushroom Kingdom. As I journeyed through this fantastical world, I couldn't help but appreciate the tunes that accompanied Mario and Luigi on their adventure.

Brian Tyler, the composer behind the film's score, had the monumental task of paying homage to Koji Kondo's iconic Super Mario music while also adding his unique spin. I must say, he did a commendable job. The melodies felt familiar yet fresh, striking a balance between honoring the classics and offering something new.

Speaking of balance, "The Super Mario Bros. Movie" continually strived for it, not just in its music but also in its overall approach. It was clear that the creators wanted to appeal to both die-hard fans and newcomers to the Mario universe. While it succeeded in catering to dedicated fans with its references and nods, it also aimed to be accessible and enjoyable for those less familiar with the games.

The Super Mario Bros. Movie's Appeal

This appeal to a wide audience was a double-edged sword. On one hand, it ensured that the movie had a broad viewership, but on the other hand, it presented the challenge of satisfying diverse expectations. The film managed to strike a chord with fans who grew up with Mario while introducing the world of pipes, mushrooms, and plumbers to a new generation.

For someone like me, who has fond memories of countless hours spent playing Super Mario games, the movie was a treat. The nostalgic music, the familiar sound effects, and the clever references brought a wave of nostalgia that made me feel like a kid again, holding a controller in my hand.

Adapting beloved video game franchises to the silver screen is no easy feat, as we've seen in the past with mixed results. "The Super Mario Bros. Movie" tackled this challenge head-on, and while it had its share of shortcomings, it also had moments of brilliance that showcased the potential of video game adaptations when done right.

The soundtrack of "The Super Mario Bros. Movie" played a pivotal role in enhancing the film's nostalgic charm while also striking a balance between the familiar and the new.

Final Thoughts

As I wrap up my thoughts on "The Super Mario Bros. Movie," it's evident that this cinematic adventure had its moments of success and its fair share of shortcomings. It embarked on a journey to bring the beloved video game franchise to life on the big screen, and while it didn't hit every mark, it certainly had its charms.

The movie's success lies in its ability to capture the nostalgia of Super Mario while offering something new for both fans and newcomers. It embraced the whimsical world of the Mushroom Kingdom and brought it to life with vibrant animation and memorable music. However, it stumbled in areas like storytelling and character development, leaving some viewers wanting more depth from the plot and its inhabitants.

"The Super Mario Bros. Movie" is a stepping stone in the ever-evolving world of video game adaptations. It showcased the potential for these adaptations to be both nostalgic and accessible, while also reminding us of the challenges they face in translating interactive experiences into linear narratives. As a fan of the games, I'm hopeful that future adaptations will continue to improve upon the formula.

If I were to give this movie a rating, I'd say it's a solid 7 out of 10 warp pipes.

Rating: ★★★★★★★☆☆☆  (7/10)

While it may not have reached the heights of some other animated films, it certainly succeeded in delivering a fun and colorful adventure that pays homage to the iconic plumber brothers.

Before wrapping up, a word of caution to parents: "The Super Mario Bros. Movie" is generally family-friendly, but it does have some action sequences and mild peril that might be a bit intense for very young children. As with any movie, it's a good idea for parents to check out reviews and ratings to make sure it's suitable for their kids.

Despite its flaws, the movie carries positive themes of teamwork, friendship, and the power of resilience. Mario and Luigi's unwavering determination to save the Mushroom Kingdom serves as a reminder that even in the face of daunting challenges, we can overcome them with the help of our friends.

"The Super Mario Bros. Movie" is a delightful romp through a beloved video game world, and while it may not have achieved perfection, it's a step in the right direction for video game adaptations. It's a fun ride for fans and a colorful introduction for newcomers, and it leaves us with the hope that the future of video game movies holds even more magic and surprises.

'Super Mario Bros. Movie' Review Did the Movie Live Up to the Hype

Author: Richie Davis

Author/Writer - Richie Davis

Introducing Richie Davis! Armed with a Bachelor's in Journalism, Richie's career journey has been a reel adventure. From editing videos to crafting compelling narratives, he's now our go-to guru for all things cinematic. When he's not busy diving into the deep end of Movie mysteries, you'll find him swimming through the latest releases or binge watching TV Shows, dissecting flicks like a true Entertainment detective.

Leave a Comment

1 × two =